Ben Nye is the brand for high-quality stage- and screen-worthy cosmetics (this stuff will not scorch your skin, unlike other, ahem, “Spirited” brands). This Stage Blood is the go-to for gore; a little goes a long way, so apply with care and wait for it to congeal into a beautiful bloodbath. Bonus: It tastes like zesty mint and is safe to use around your mouth! $6.99